How could spot prices affect my bill?

To help you to estimate the risks of buying electricity at the spot price, we’ve created two examples to show you the possible impact on your bill.

Before you refer to the examples, you should decide which of the following applies to your situation:

  • you’re a flexible household that manages to use much of its power at the time of the day when the spot price is lowest
  • you’re a normal household that uses most of its power in the morning and early evening when the spot price tends to be relatively high.

These are examples of what spot prices can do in severe circumstances. Nonetheless, spot prices could be higher or last for longer than set out in these examples.

Example 1 – high prices for several months

Spot prices can increase to several times the normal level, for several months in a row. This might happen if South Island hydro lakes are low, because of low rainfall. The system operator publishes regular reports on hydro lake levels.

This table shows the effects of high spot prices on the spot-priced portion of an electricity bill. In each of the situations the spot-priced portion of the electricity bill increases by nearly three times, as shown in the fifth column. The sixth column (on the far right) shows the additional cost if the high prices continue for three months.

What is your billing period?How much power do you use in winter?Are you a flexible or normal household?Cost in normal winter conditions*Cost in high spot price conditions*Extra cost - high spot prices for 3 consecutive months^
Weekly Low use (140kWh) Flexible $14 $38 $315
Normal $16 $44 $365
Medium use (230kWh) Flexible $22 $62 $520
Normal $26 $71 $595
High use (350kWh) Flexible $34 $95 $790
Normal $39 $109 $910
Monthly Low use (600kWh) Flexible $59 $162 $310
Normal $67 $186 $355
Medium use (1000kWh) Flexible $98 $270 $520
Normal $112 $311 $595
High user (1500kWh)

Flexible

$147 $405 $775
Normal $169 $466 $895

* per winter billing period including GST. Additional non-spot price charges and associated GST will apply. Non-spot charges and GST make up the sizable portion of a typical bill and include payment for electricity transmission, lines and metering.
^ including GST, over and above what your normal spot priced winter power bill would be. Is rounded to the nearest $5.

Example 2 - very high prices for eight hours

It is possible for spot prices to increase to hundreds of times the normal level for a period as short as half an hour. This might happen if a power station suddenly shuts down and there is limited back-up generation available.

This example assumes that the ‘flexible’ household does not receive warning of the high spot price in time to switch off appliances. In practice, there may be no advance warning of high prices.

This table shows the effects of eight hours of very high spot prices on the spot-priced portion of an electricity bill. In each of the weekly situations, the spot-priced portion of the electricity bill (shown in the last column) increases by about seven times. In each of the monthly situations, the spot-priced portion of the bill increases by nearly two and a half times.

What is your billing period?How much power do you use in winter?Are you a flexible or normal household?Cost in normal winter conditions*Cost in very  high spot price for 8 hours*
Weekly Low use (140kWh) Flexible $14 $94
Normal $16 $111
Medium use (230kWh) Flexible $22 $154
Normal $26 $182
High use (350kWh) Flexible $34 $234
Normal $39 $277
Monthly      Low use (600kWh)  Flexible $59 $137
Normal  $67  $161
Medium use (1000kWh)   Flexible  $98 $229
Normal  $112 $268
High use (1500kWh)  Flexible  $147 $343
Normal  $169 $402

* per winter billing period including GST. Additional non-spot charges and associated GST will apply. Non-spot charges and GST make up a sizable portion of a typical bill and include payment for electricity transmission, lines and metering.

 

For the technically minded…

The following table sets out our assumptions about spot prices and the increases we make to account for households using a greater proportion of their power at high-priced times.

PriceAverage spot priceIncrease for normal householdsIncrease for flexible households
Normal winter spot prices (used in both examples) $0.085/kWh We add 15% to the average spot price None
High winter spot prices (used only in example 1) $0.235/kWh We add 15% to the average spot price None
Very high winter spot prices (used only in example 2) $10.00/kWh We add 25% to the average spot price during the eight-hour period We add 5% to the average spot price during the eight-hour period